Quote:
Originally Posted by Tormato
Ditmarsher 74 (dtm from sowing) flavor - 4
Cole 82 - 6
Latah 82 - 5
Pearly Pink Orange 82 - 4
Pink Princess 84 - 6
Sun Gold F1 84 - 9+
Forest Fire 85 - 5
Pervaya Lyubov 85 - 8 to 9
SNFLA 88 premature ripening/BER - 9+
Jagodka 91 -5
Visitation Valley 91 -5
Granny's Heart NOT (#29) 91 - 8 to 9
Prue NOT 91 - 6
Rhode Island Early 92 - 6
Mat Su Express 93 - 8
experimental PL yellow cherry 93 -6
grading scale...
4 - awful, but not dreadful
5 - OK
6 - OK, but only combined with other things
7 - very good, but not in the elite category
8 - excellent, stand alone eating quality
9+ - superb
|
Of the ones I've grown,and there a lot on your list of those,I can agree with your flavor ratings.
BUT,here are the ones where I don't agree,to each their own, as is oft said.
Visitation Valley and Latah,I would rate 1 to 2.
As for Latah, and some other comments here you go.
http://www.tomatoville.com/newreply....reply&p=710238
Of Dr. Boes ones my all time,or close to it BAD BAD one is Sandpoint, the link above tells you why.
And I told Glenn to never ask me to eat it again unless it was enrobed in dark chocolate.
And of course I can't comment on all the ones that weren't what they were supposed to be.
Carolyn