I hesitate to even step into this quagmire.
The human side of this is that we are all? human and we do make mistakes. The stringent and accurate side says that accuracy in descriptions is very important from a historical perspective. From my perspective, what matters most is whether or not a tomato tastes good when properly prepared.
Is W3 a nice guy? I'm sure he is. Has he published some obvious inaccuracies? Yes, and they are fairly significant. Is it something to argue over? Not really, just understand where he is coming from and take it with a grain of salt.
DarJones
|